Asset And Liability Management
Transfer Price
Transfer pricing is a method that would reflect in each business the cost of funding and the impact it has on each product margin. There are many ways to calculate the cost of funding and the effects of regulation directly or indirectly. In Europe, since the 2007 to 2008 financial crisis, there has been much concern about the cost imposed by the minimum size required of liquid assets and the returns provided by them, vis-à-vis other assets that can provide a better return, of course with potential higher risk. That is the main impact from a regulatory point of view when calculating the transfer price. The level of regulation here is much lighter compared to other components in the bank's operation.
Banks use various methods to calculate transfer pricing. To accurately assess the cost of funding, it is essential to understand both the cost and tenure of funds – that is, how much the bank is paying for deposits 'on paper' and for how long those funds remain available. However, contractual terms do not always reflect the actual stability of deposits, particularly with retail deposits. Therefore, periodic analysis of deposit behaviour, known as 'Behaviouralisation,' is crucial for effective risk management.
The ALM or Treasury department regularly provides the ALCO with an analysis of the range of core deposit behaviours. Interestingly, retail current accounts, which in most cases have a zero cost of funding as they do not pay interest, and are available for immediate withdrawal, consistently keep significant balances over time. The same applies to fixed-rate retail deposits.
Some banks do an overall appraisal of funding cost and apply it linearly across all business units, moving just market risk to Treasury and applying, only when needed, an overprice based on risk. This is simpler, but this simplicity will affect the competitiveness of businesses and the true measure of performance of each business.
From a Retail point of view, banks should ensure they apply the cost of funding based on each business' own cost and terms to the maximum extent possible. That is needed to provide Retail with a margin that can absorb a cost that is not a direct cost of its customers' deposits, which is the distribution cost of the business, not shared by Commercial or Corporate banking.
When calculating transfer pricing, it's crucial to account for the real nature of Retail deposits, regardless of the contract terms. The cost of remunerating these deposits (the interest rate paid – which is sometimes zero) must be factored in because Retail banking operates with significant distribution costs. These costs cover everything needed to keep the Retail business running – branches, call centers, ATMs, specialized sales teams, and more. The margin earned from deposits is essential to covering them.
So, any proper transfer pricing model must reflect this reality: the extra margin from deposits isn't just profit – it's what keeps the entire retail banking infrastructure up and running.
What must be understood is that without the distribution structure, such sticky and low-cost source of funds would never exist, and the bank would have to fund its loans mainly through professional funding, which is more expensive and less stable.
A good way to view it would be if the bank could split the business into isolated units and could measure the cost of funding in each business based on its capacity to bring funds, to understand the tenure, stability, and cost. Retail, with its ability to capture deposits from individuals at zero or low interest rates (mainly demand and savings deposits), would have the lowest cost of funding across all units, providing a true measurement of profitability.
With the above analysis and understanding, the discussion on transfer price can start, and different ways to compensate Retail can be agreed. This could be achieved by either matching the true cost to business, portfolio, and origination, or by an inter-business remuneration on surplus usage of funding transferred from Retail to other businesses.
The Retail professional banker needs to understand how their bank calculates the cost of funding and how it applies to each business line and/or products. It is also important to ensure that the critical role played by Retail is rewarded, understanding that such a reward is fundamental to pay for the distribution cost and providing the true measure of profitability.
The bank must understand that any interest rate risk will mainly affect professional funding, which is mainly used by Commercial and Corporate, where a bank normally has the lower interest rates on loans.
