Retail Banking Institute Logo
Lafferty Group
Certified International Retail Banker Certificate

Environmental, Social And Governance (ESG) Principles

Consumer Expectations for ESG Principles

Globally, consumers expect their retail banks to align with ESG principles, reflecting a broader societal shift toward sustainability and ethical business practices. As awareness of climate change, social inequality, and corporate accountability grows, customers demand that banks go beyond profit-making and actively contribute to a more sustainable and responsible financial system. While expectations vary by region and demographic, clear trends emerge in what consumers seek from their banks in terms of ESG commitments.

Environmental Responsibility: Sustainable Banking and Green Finance

Environmental concerns are now integral to consumer expectations. Many believe banks should lead in financing sustainability efforts, particularly by supporting green investments and reducing funding for environmentally harmful industries. There is pressure on banks to phase out fossil fuel financing and instead support renewable energy, clean technology, and environmentally responsible businesses.

Beyond financing, consumers expect banks to minimise their environmental footprint. Digital banking, paperless transactions, and sustainable branch designs are growing in importance. Some banks have adopted carbon-neutral operations and issued green bonds, but consumers increasingly demand transparency in how sustainability goals are achieved rather than accepting marketing claims at face value.

Social Impact: Financial Inclusion and Ethical Banking

Consumers expect banks to play a proactive role in economic and social well-being. Financial inclusion is a major concern, especially in developing economies where banking access remains limited. Customers want banks to extend affordable credit to small businesses, entrepreneurs, and underserved communities to support financial stability.

Ethical banking is also a key expectation. Consumers demand fair treatment in lending and fees to prevent the exploitation of vulnerable customers. Diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) within banking institutions are becoming more relevant, with customers preferring banks that promote workforce diversity and equitable hiring practices. Additionally, corporate philanthropy, such as support for local charities and community development, is seen as a reflection of a bank's social commitment.

Governance and Transparency: Building Trust Through Accountability

Trust in banking has improved since the post-GFC era but remains fragile, making governance and transparency critical. Customers are wary of vague sustainability promises, and investors expect clear, verifiable ESG reports. Transparency in policies, such as investment disclosures, ethical lending practices, and executive accountability, is becoming a factor in customer loyalty.

Triodos Bank is a leading example of transparency in banking, publicly disclosing all businesses and projects it finances. It follows strict ethical lending criteria, finances only sustainability-aligned organisations, and holds B Corp certification, ensuring high standards in social, environmental, and transparency practices. It ties executive pay to long-term ESG performance and maintains a 'no-bonus' policy, reinforcing responsible banking principles.

Regulatory compliance is no longer sufficient; consumers want banks to lead with integrity, ensuring corporate governance prioritises long-term sustainability over short-term profits. Issues such as fair pricing, responsible data management, and anti-corruption measures are increasingly important.

BBVA (Banco Bilbao Vizcaya Argentaria) exemplifies this shift by offering transparent pricing, strong data protection, and an 'Ethical Channel' for reporting misconduct. Its 2020 Sustainable Business Report highlights its commitment to responsible and transparent banking.

Consumer Behaviour: Shifts in Banking Preferences

Younger generations, particularly Millennials and Gen Z, are more likely to switch banks based on sustainability and ethical considerations. Consumers are also showing interest in sustainable investment products and impact-driven banking solutions.

However, scepticism remains and concerns about 'greenwashing', where organisations exaggerate ESG commitments, are rising. Consumers now look for independent ESG ratings, third-party certifications, and concrete evidence that banks genuinely uphold sustainability promises.

Criticism of ESG in Banking

While many banks are making progress, criticisms fall into three categories:

1. Greenwashing and Regulatory Action

Some organisations overstate their ESG efforts without substantial action or evidence, a practice known as greenwashing. Investors and regulators are increasingly scrutinising such claims. The Net Zero Banking Alliance, launched during COP26 in Glasgow, commits banks to achieving net-zero emissions by 2050, with a 50% reduction target by 2030. However, measuring progress remains a challenge, leading to updated 2024 guidelines requiring:

  • Public disclosure of long-term and intermediate targets;
  • Establishment of emissions baselines;
  • Reporting of lending, investment, and capital markets activities;
  • Adoption of science-based decarbonisation scenarios .

Following the 2024 US election, some banks left the Net Zero Banking Alliance due to shifting political priorities, but regulatory bodies like the European Central Bank (ECB) continue to push for climate-related risk disclosures.

2. Short-term Results vs Long-term ESG Impact

Most banks owned by shareholders focus on short-term financial results. Critics argue some ESG initiatives focus on immediate results rather than meaningful, long-term change. Boards must balance short-term targets with sustainable, long-term strategies.

A 2021 Edelman Trust Barometer report found that 86% of US investors believe companies exaggerate ESG progress, and 72% globally doubt firms will meet commitments.

3. Fragmented ESG Metrics and Reporting

ESG metrics and reporting standards are inconsistent, making it difficult for stakeholders, including banks, to compare performance. The reliance on voluntary rather than mandatory regulations further complicates accountability.

Scope 1, 2, and 3 Emissions Reporting Challenges

Scope 1 emissions are direct emissions from company-owned or controlled sources, such as fuel combustion in buildings and company vehicles. Scope 2 emissions are indirect emissions from purchased electricity, heating, cooling, or steam. Scope 3 emissions include all other indirect emissions in a company's value chain, such as supply chain activities, employee commuting, business travel, and financed emissions. For banks, Scope 3, especially financed emissions from loans and investments, represents the largest share of their carbon footprint.

Regulations guiding emissions reporting are complex and include the GHG Protocol, Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD), and EU Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD), which require banks to disclose Scope 1, 2, and 3 emissions. The SEC Climate Disclosure Rules in the U.S. mandate Scope 1 and 2 reporting, with Scope 3 required in certain cases. The UK SECR and ISSB standards also push for transparency in emissions data.

Reporting challenges include:

  • Data availability and accuracy: banks struggle to obtain reliable emissions data from suppliers, clients, and investment portfolios, making Scope 3 reporting particularly difficult;
  • Measurement complexity: financed emissions require standardised methodologies and assumptions, which vary across industries and geographies;
  • Regulatory uncertainty, with so many regulators and evolving disclosure requirements create compliance challenges, especially for multinational banks;
  • Reputational and financial risks: banks face scrutiny over greenwashing and risk losing investors if emissions targets lack credibility.

Banks are responding through a number of initiatives:

  • Enhancing data collection: banks like Barclays and HSBC are partnering with fintech firms and climate data providers to improve emissions tracking for their loan portfolios;
  • Standardising methodologies: any institutions use the Partnership for Carbon Accounting Financials (PCAF) framework to ensure consistency in measuring financed emissions;
  • Integrating ESG into decision-making: banks are embedding ESG criteria into risk management, loan approvals, and investment strategies;
  • Commitments to net-zero: initiatives like the Net Zero Banking Alliance (NZBA) push banks to set science-based emissions targets and increase transparency in reporting.

Is Emissions Reporting Banks' Biggest ESG Challenge in 2025?

Emissions reporting, particularly Scope 3 (financed emissions), is a major ESG challenge for banks in 2025 due to increasing regulatory scrutiny, investor expectations, and reputational risks. With regulations like the EU CSRD, SEC Climate Disclosure Rules, and ISSB standards expanding requirements for climate-related disclosures, banks face growing pressure to provide accurate, transparent, and verifiable emissions data.

However, it is not the only major challenge or criticism, and banks also struggle with greenwashing concerns, balancing long-term ESG impact with short-term profitability and social and governance issues such as financial inclusion, diversity, ethical lending, and data privacy are rising priorities.

Will It Be Banks' Biggest ESG Challenge by 2030?

By 2030, emissions reporting will remain important, but other ESG challenges may rise in prominence:

  • Transition finance and climate risk adaptation: banks will need to fund industries transitioning to low-carbon models while managing climate-related credit risks;
  • Biodiversity and nature-based risks: regulators may expand reporting requirements beyond carbon emissions to include biodiversity and environmental impact;
  • AI ethics and digital responsibility: the rise of AI-driven banking raises concerns about data privacy, bias in credit decisions, and ethical AI governance;
  • Evolving stakeholder expectations: consumer and investor pressure for greater ESG accountability will continue to shape banking priorities.

In summary, while emissions reporting is a top challenge in 2025, banks must also address broader ESG risks to stay compliant and competitive by 2030.