Retail Banking Institute Logo
Lafferty Group
Certified International Retail Banker Certificate

Environmental, Social And Governance (ESG) Principles

2025's Political Backlash

In 2025, a notable backlash against sustainability has emerged, driven by political shifts and economic challenges. In the United States, political pressure from the White House has led to a significant decline in asset managers' support for climate and diversity initiatives, with only 1.4% of related shareholder resolutions approved in 2024, down from over 20% in 2021.

US banks are significantly scaling back their public commitments to sustainability and diversity initiatives, largely due to intensified political and legal pressures. The new regulatory environment scrutinising ESG efforts has prompted major financial institutions to reassess their positions. For instance, Citigroup has discontinued its diversity-related hiring standards and rebranded its Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) team to 'Talent Management and Engagement.' Similarly, Goldman Sachs has eliminated its Initial Public Offering (IPO) diversity mandate, which previously required companies to have diverse boards for public listings. Additionally, banks like JPMorgan Chase and Morgan Stanley are removing DEI language from their public communications to mitigate legal risks associated with recent policy changes. Despite these retreats, some institutions, such as Bank of America, continue to emphasise their environmental sustainability initiatives, including a commitment to mobilise $1 trillion by 2030 to support a low-carbon economy. This divergence in approaches reflects the complex landscape U.S. banks navigate amid evolving political and societal expectations regarding sustainability and diversity.

In the UK, major banks like Barclays and NatWest have removed climate targets from executive bonus schemes, reflecting a broader trend of distancing from environmental commitments. HSBC has delayed its net-zero emission target for its operations from 2030 to 2050, citing challenges faced by clients and suppliers in reducing their carbon footprints.

This backlash affects retail banks by creating uncertainty around sustainability commitments, potentially eroding customer trust and investor confidence. To navigate this, banks can reaffirm their dedication to sustainability by setting realistic, transparent goals and integrating ESG factors into long-term strategies. Engaging stakeholders through clear communication and demonstrating genuine impact can help rebuild credibility. Additionally, offering green financial products and services can meet the growing consumer demand for sustainable banking options, aligning profitability with positive societal impact.

The Paris Climate Accords

As of February 2025, the United States is the only country to have withdrawn from the Paris Climate Accord. Despite the US exit, the Paris Agreement continues to have widespread global support, with 194 states and the European Union remaining committed to its goals.

Consumer Aren't Necessarily Aligned with the Backlash

Consumer attitudes toward ESG initiatives present a complex picture. While political and corporate spheres, particularly in the United States, exhibit a notable backlash against ESG principles, consumer support for sustainability remains significant. Research from Key ESG indicates that 88% of consumers express increased loyalty to companies advocating for social or environmental issues. A joint study by McKinsey and NielsenIQ reveals that products with ESG-related claims have experienced growth, suggesting that consumers are willing to support sustainable products with their purchasing decisions.

What consumers say, and what they do, sometimes differs

However, there is a discernible gap between consumers' stated intentions and their actual purchasing behaviours. The Chicago Booth Review highlights that, despite professed concerns about ESG issues, consumers often make only minor and temporary adjustments to their buying habits after learning about a company's ESG activities. This inconsistency may stem from factors such as perceived higher costs of sustainable products, limited availability, or scepticism toward corporate greenwashing practices.

In summary

While consumers generally support ESG initiatives and prefer companies that demonstrate genuine commitment to social and environmental responsibility, this support does not always translate into consistent purchasing behaviour. The current backlash against ESG in political and corporate arenas does not appear to be fully aligned with consumer sentiments, which continue to favour sustainability efforts, albeit with some reservations.